|
Understanding how to use when and while becomes more
complicated when you realize that
native speakers often
use when for while,
but they don't use while
for when:
OK:
When / While I was driving
home, I ran out of gas.
I ran out of gas when / while
I was driving home.
Not OK:
*While I ran out of gas, I
was driving home.
*I was driving home while
I ran out of gas.
_______________________
OK:
When / While Jim was working
in Chicago, he
bought his first car.
Jim bought his first car when
/ while he was working
in Chicago.
Not OK:
*While Jim bought his first
car, he was working in Chicago.
*Jim was working in Chicago
while he bought his first car.
_______________________
Not OK:
*While Julia fell down, she
hurt her ankle.
*Julia hurt her ankle while
she fell down.
Not OK:
*While Diego lost the race,
he almost cried. / *Diego almost cried while he lost the race.
_______________________
OK:
When / While the chairman
was speaking, everyone
was listening intently.
Everyone was listening intently
when / while the
chairman was speaking.
OK:
While / When Jane was driving
to work, she
was planning her day.
Jane was planning her day
while / when she
was driving to work.
______________________________________________
Special
Note:
Notice that when and while
are not always interchangeable:
OK:
When Julia fell down, Fred
helped her get up.
Fred helped Julia get up when
she fell down.
Not OK:
*When Fred helped Julia get
up, she fell down.
*Julia fell down when Fred
helped her get up.
OK:
When Diego lost the race,
he almost cried.
Diego almost cried when he
lost the race.
Not OK:
*When Diego almost cried,
he lost the race.
*Diego lost the race when
he almost cried.
OK:
While the chairman was speaking,
everyone was listening
intently.
Everyone was listening intently
while the chairman was speaking.
Not OK:
*While everyone was listening
intently, the chairman was speaking.
*The chairman was speaking
while everyone was listening intently.
|